Marketing Has Outgrown Marketing
The role of the CMO is changing. Between AI, data and the business, marketing leadership is increasingly about making the right choices.
on

There is an image that comes to mind when I think about the work of a CMO today: a table where dishes keep arriving, but none of the previous ones are ever cleared away. The brand is still there. So is creativity. Channels, content, media, experience, CRM, data, technology, measurement, privacy and growth. Then came personalisation, automation and, more recently, AI agents. Nothing has truly replaced anything else. It has all simply accumulated.
Perhaps this is the most interesting starting point for looking ahead to 2027: we are not facing yet another marketing transformation. We are facing a shift in the very nature of the work of those who lead it.
When everything is marketing, who brings the pieces together?
For a long time, there were relatively comfortable boundaries. Advertising built awareness. CRM managed the relationship. Digital took care of digital channels. Sales sold. Customer service solved problems. Today, those boundaries matter mainly on organisational charts.
For an individual, seeing an advert, walking into a shop, opening an app, speaking to a chatbot, receiving an email or trying to return a product are all moments within the same relationship. And a brand can spend millions saying, “we know our customers”, only to undo that promise in thirty seconds by asking, for the third time, for information it already has. It is in this gap, between what the brand promises and what the organisation can actually deliver, that an increasing share of the CMO’s work now lies.
And now, machines can make decisions
The arrival of AI agents makes this equation far more interesting. Until now, we have mainly used artificial intelligence to help us do things: write, research, analyse, recommend, create images and accelerate tasks. The next step is different. We will have systems that do not simply help to execute marketing. They will execute it themselves.
One agent decides which content to use. Another personalises an interaction. Another selects an audience. Another triggers an action. And all of them learn at a pace no human team could possibly keep up with manually. So the question is no longer, “how can we use AI in marketing?” That question has aged quickly. The more interesting question is this: when an increasing proportion of marketing is carried out by machines, where do we want human intention to remain?
Efficiency without intention simply produces more things. More messages. More versions. More stimuli. More noise. And the world hardly seems to need more noise…
The new luxury is knowing how to choose
We also have more data than ever before. We know behaviours, journeys, conversions, drop-offs, preferences and signals. We can test almost anything and measure a considerable part of what happens. And yet, I am not sure we are proportionally better at making decisions. Perhaps because the scarce resource has changed. For years, we sought more information. Now, we need better judgement.
Judgement to understand which signal matters and which is merely noise. To know when to personalise and when to leave someone alone. To decide what to automate and where to introduce deliberate friction. To recognise when optimising a metric is quietly making the experience worse. And, above all, to make choices when the numbers do not offer an unambiguous answer.
Not everything we can measure deserves to drive decisions
It is no longer enough for CMOs to demonstrate that a campaign worked or that the brand gained awareness. They are expected to explain, with increasing precision, how marketing contributes to growth, helps win customers, keeps them for longer and creates value for the business. That expectation is legitimate. The problem begins when we value what we can measure more than what genuinely creates value. Because numbers have an irresistible quality: they give us a sense of certainty. And in marketing, not everything that matters fits neatly into a dashboard.
A conversion appears immediately on a results sheet. Trust does not. A reduction in customer acquisition cost (CAC) is visible within the quarter. The impact of years of brand consistency is far less obedient to the financial calendar. Leading marketing will also mean resisting the temptation to confuse what we can count with what truly counts. Not to avoid accountability for results, but precisely to take full responsibility for them.
CMO is becoming too small a title for such a big role
When we look at all of this together, the strangeness of the moment becomes clear. We ask the same leader to think about the next interaction and the next five years. To protect the brand’s identity while enabling millions of personalised experiences. To give machines autonomy and set their limits. To increase efficiency without making the brand generic. To prove results today without mortgaging what will generate results tomorrow.
It is a role full of contradictions. And perhaps that is exactly the capability that will distinguish the best CMOs in 2027: not eliminating these tensions, but knowing how to manage them, make choices between them and ensure they all point in the same direction.
Technology will continue to change. So will platforms. New agents will emerge, and systems will become increasingly autonomous. But this will not diminish the importance of marketing leadership. It will probably do the opposite. Because the greater our ability to do things, the more important it will be to know what to choose.
What to automate and what to keep human. What to optimise and what to protect. Where to pursue efficiency and where to accept that some value takes time to build. Perhaps that is the biggest shift in the role of the CMO: moving beyond simply leading marketing to becoming the person who ensures coherence between what a brand promises, what an organisation can deliver and what the business needs to build.
In a world where almost anything will be possible, leading marketing will increasingly mean knowing what is worth doing. Or, to return to the opening metaphor, which dishes to choose.
Article by Ester Leotte, Head of Tangity Portugal